This is the fist book I’ve picked up from the Man Booker longlist. Yes I had some trouble getting a few of them while I was in the States. In fact, I only managed to pick up two, We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves and To Rise Again at a Decent Hour. Since then I’ve managed to pick up a few others either in e-book form or ordering physical copies online. Happily the first two I picked up this summer have been put on the shortlist. Is that a sign that I can choose a good book by its cover? Hmmm! Probably not. Trying to acquire a few of these longlisted intriguing novels, I decided to pick up We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves first.
After reading the description on the back cover I was worried that it would be contrived and gimmicky. Some say the description is a big spoiler however I found the book was more than what was described on the back cover and anyway everybody has heard or knows the basic principle of the novel. Fowler created a story full of anxiousness, mystery, and sensitivity. We follow a dysfunctional family through the eyes of the main character, Rosemary Cooke. Or is she the main character? Rosemary is quirky, slightly guarded, highly intelligent, and honest. She is quite the reliable narrator, which we can see clearly when she second guesses some of her memories as she recounts the first few years of her life living with her “sister” Fern and brother Lowell.
The novel opens with the voice of a character who is hiding herself and her pain. A pain that she has held within herself for many years. We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves is Rosemary’s attempt to come to terms with all that is and has been wrong with her family since the addition of a baby chimpanzee to their family called Fern. Who would have known the consequences of this addition to the family?
Rosemary’s parents are distant and acting as they see fit or as they would think is necessary. Rosemary’s relationship with her father seems strained beyond repair. As the story continues, it becomes clear where the problems lie. The entire family has strained relationships with each other due to Fern’s appearance. It’s as if Fern became the focal point of the family and no other member of the family saw the other family members’ needs.
Fowler constructed the story in a way that you don’t get the full picture until the very last page. Starting in the middle of the story, clues about the Cooke family are strewn through the pages almost as if it were a journal. Rosemary is witty and at times brutally honest. She gives us all the information we need to know, facts included. The language Fowler uses and her writing style contribute to the novel’s emotional power. I was marvelled at Fowler’s brilliance in choosing certain vocabulary and expression. Communication and language were two of the primary themes in this novel and we as readers got to have a closer look at these themes from many angles. Communication and language are what initially separates the Cooke’s, however it is what drew them closer to Fern.
I couldn’t help it but I found myself searching for information on chimpanzees that had been raised with humans and ran across a few You Tube videos. There was something seriously unsettling, eery, and lugubrious about it all. It just didn’t seem right from the child’s point of view and certainly not from the chimpanzees’. I found this book incredibly moving and informative. I think it might have a good chance to win the Man Booker but who knows since I haven’t read any of the other shortlisted ones yet. However, this one is a must read and is very difficult to put down.
Karen Joy Fowler is known for having written sixteen books in total including The Jane Austen Book Club, which was adapted to film in 2007. Some of her other novels are Wit’s End, Sarah Canary, Sister Noon, Black Glass, The Sweetheart Season, What I Didn’t See: Stories, and many more. She broke into writing with her well-known collection of science-fiction short stories called Artificial Things in 1986. She also won the Pen/Faulkner Award 2014. She’s been lucky to have been chosen for the Man Booker shortlist, for the first year that the competition was open to authors outside of the Commonwealth, as well as being nominated for a 2014 Nebula Award. We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves is definitely a five-star book not to miss out on.
14 Replies to “We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves”
You enjoyed this far more than I did. I enjoyed parts of it (the scene at the beginning in the college dining room was funny) but I thought some of the ways Fowler told us about the history of this kind of research was really clumsy
I didn’t find it clumsy at all. It’s tom Rosemary’s point of view so it’s not going to be very scientific. She’s writing about her feelings and her missed relationship with her brother and distant relationship with her parents. I feel the story is very well told. I know some people don’t like it but there were parts that really spoke to me – language.
it was meant to be Rosemary’s voice but it really didn’t sound like it.
Who’s voice did it sound like to you?
Great review. I loved this book – the ending had me weeping on a packed commuter train! It’s the only one I’ve read from the Booker shortlist – I hope the others are as good…
Yes it was very sad the ending. I really wasn’t expecting it to be so very good. Now on to the others on the shortlist however I’ll be skipping The Narrow road to the Deep. War novels no sorry no can do. Will probably pick up To Rise to a Decent Hour next. What about you?
I think I’d like to read Ali Smith next, as I usually enjoy her writing. Will you be reviewing the Ferris? I tried reading And Then We Came To the End, but didn’t get on with it – I’d love to hear your thoughts on To Rise…. so I know whether to give him another chance!
The plan is to start that one next, although I haven’t heard anything good about it. So we’ll see…..
I’ve read half of The Narrow Road and had to put it aside and take on a woman’s perspective of war in Vera Brittain’s Testament of Youth instead. The brutality of what men put each other through in times of war was too much for me,not sure if I will finish it or not, despite it being well written.
I hadn’t planned on reading that one at all. I just can’t read too much brutality. It really does my head in. I’m going to stick to the rest of the shortlist and some from the longlist. I think you would like this one. I’m planning on picking up To Rise a t a Decent Hour although I haven’t heard one good word about it as yet.
I’m in a reading slow mo, so unlikely to get to anything much else, its taken me 3 weeks to read 300 pages of the Simone DeBeauvoir memoir I’m reading and thinking of reading an Elena Ferrante novely after that, have been wanting to read her for months and months, so sticking to my own desires rather than prize lists for now – well, if I ever finish DeBeauvoir that is 🙂
I totally understand. I’m getting to be a little the same. I want to read what I want when I want. Too many buddy reason You Tube and book club reads on Goodreads. I need to slow down on all of that to get through my TBR list for the next few months. Happy reading Claire! 😀
I just saw this discussed on The (First Tuesday) Book Club and immediately wanted to read it. I’m looking forward to it. Great review.
Thanks! I saw it reviewed there too. Check it out! I think you’ll like it.
You must log in to post a comment.